I realized suddenly that we had been duped. That Laapet had used Deborah and me—and our faith in her honesty. It came as a greater shock than I imagined it would. The bubble had burst and these proud, untouchable people had become suspect and ugly with one lie. The disillusionment made me belligerent. "She is Pundra Doh's wife," I said to Vechi. "She is Pundra's concubine," Vechi said gently. "She will be my wife." "And what of her poor children in Ul?" "They are Pundra's children. Under the system she is a communal mother. They are with their true mother in Ul." "She lied," I said obstinately. I had been deceived into sympathy. She had used a powerful and terrible weapon and I remembered the ancient proverb, "God deliver us from the lies of honest men." But Vechi perceived my disillusionment and all of its meaning. "Yes," he said. "It is necessary for others to lie before they can live by our code." "You can't blame her duplicity on us," I said. "Only in so far as we are not acceptable to the people who live in truth. And those who would live with us must break into truth. As she has been forced to do—to protect our secret. It has not been easy for her." "Steve, Steve, can't you see that it must have been terrible for her?" I looked at Deborah. "Yes, I suppose it must have been. But—how could you have met?" "It happened three years ago," Vechi told us. "There was an accident in the desert. Laapet's driver had been killed in an explosion in her machine. I came along quite by chance and I helped her. It was not difficult to fall in love with her." I watched the man unbelievingly. For three years he, too, had practised deceit. He had deliberately permitted rumor to distort his purpose and character and reputation. And during those three years, his frequent and mysterious trips—were they to see Laapet? I asked him. "No," he said, "I have been building a place of refuge for us. We could not stay here, and where could we be at ease on Earth?" "And that is why you are taking the Starfish, to make the trip?" "I am borrowing it," Vechi said. "Rocz and the pilot will return it once we have reached our